First up, let me say that I’m sorry for the long silence. It wasn’t voluntary. I actually tried a few times to write posts, but what I produced was unpublishable.
Since the last blog article, I fell into a gully of worsening symptoms that seemed to have no end. Over the months, I made several visits to doctors but, apart from considering the possibility of long covid on top of the clinical burnout I presumably still had, they couldn’t give me a confident answer. Eventually it became so bad that I had to dig deep into savings and non-existent energy for an overseas flight to recommended medical specialists. Covid was ruled out first with a negative IgG. After a detailed investigation into my case history and weeks of tests, the consensus was that the original diagnosis of burnout was wrong and that I’ve had ME/CFS all along, almost 5 years to date. (I’ll stick to ME for simplicity’s sake.)
If you aren’t familiar with the disease, ME stands for myalgic encephalomyelitis. Good luck getting that one out. It’s also known as CFS (chronic fatigue syndrome), and more recently, SEID (systemic exertion intolerance disease). The name, chronic fatigue syndrome, is sometimes criticized as misleading when used outside of medical circles, because “fatigue” fails to represent the nature of the debilitation or its extent. Among other things, one experiences cognitive impairment, muscle and joint pain, sleep disfunction, and brutal payback after any exertion. Extreme tiredness (a weird sick exhaustion) is a key symptom, but the word, fatigue, in common parlance, suggests something that everyone experiences on a daily basis, something we can just overcome by toughing it out and carrying on with life as normal. Except in the mildest of cases, this really isn’t possible with ME, and attempting it is exactly how to make the disease worse and prevent recovery. The first diagnostic criterion on the cdc website is actually the inability to continue with routine activities that were possible before becoming ill.
EDIT: Just to address a potential point of confusion … The severity of the disease and the exertion level of people’s activities vary considerably, so some will be able to continue in their jobs while others can exert all the willpower they can muster and have no more success than if they were attempting to jog on broken legs.
The physical debilitation can be extreme, but I find the mental side to be worse. The closest comparison I can make is the thick, slow and woolly perception of reality that happens in the seconds following a concussion, except that it often lasted for months. The simplest obstacles that used to be mere bumps in the road became mountains.
Since getting my results, all the details that couldn’t be explained by my original diagnosis have dropped into place. It’s a pity it wasn’t detected earlier. My specialist physician actually had the opportunity to do so four years back but he declined to give any diagnosis. At the most recent consultation, when pressed, he conceded that it was the same condition he had seen before and that everything pointed to ME. The neurologist later gave me to understand that specialists (particularly the older ones who learned about the disease long before it was assigned an official ICD code) are often reluctant to diagnose ME because some doctors have tended to use it as a “dumping ground” for a range of conditions with similar symptoms. (And there are many.) These all need to be excluded by various tests, but it seems that there are cases when the tests are not done and patients are diagnosed with ME when they have something else. The unfortunate result is that some specialists are reluctant to diagnose ME even when all the tests are done and it’s the only illness left on the table. This, it appears, was my experience.
My symptoms were moderate at first, which is why I was able to hang onto a much-reduced work load and social life, but the past 18 months permitted none of that. The experience has been like body-surfing in the ocean when the interval between big waves suddenly shrinks. Where you once had stretches of calm water between the breakers, they now hit one after another, and all you can do is tumble with the whitewater and gasp for air when your head breaks the surface. Since early 2022, I’ve had two short windows of remission. Other than that, it’s been constant whitewater that is only now beginning to settle a bit.
The Gains
My first three years of illness held several cycles of remission and relapse, and it was during the windows of remission that I was able to work a few hours a day, usually for 2-6 weeks before mind and body shut down again. It’s possible that this work may have contributed to relapses (though relapses can happen even when resting), but at the time I thought my problem was burnout and that I was in recovery, hence the slow return to normal activities. Had I known what was really happening, I would have managed it differently. Yet in spite of it all, some of the best sections were written during those times.
My favourite reads reflect life in its sunny hilltops as well as its shadowed valleys, giving an honest and balanced telling of the struggle and the joy of what it means to be alive. I don’t think it’s possible to give a faithful representation of valleys without experiencing some. It’s in the valleys that we have the best opportunity to grow in empathy and respect for those in pain, and writing that touches on pain without respect or empathy is painful in itself. It’s one of many things that teaches me to be grateful for the experience.
But what I’ve gained has not been merely an understanding of struggle. Remember the magic of childhood, that thrill of discovery? I don’t think it’s lost at a particular age; rather, I think we lose it to a way of living, a way of thinking, and it can be recovered. One of the times I see this happening is after an extended illness or injury. Suddenly there is overwhelming joy in a thing as simple as being able to go out for a walk. There’s nothing like deprivation to rekindle an appreciation of life. We see it in little way too. Stars never shine so clear as when the endless clouds finally break, and the streets never look so bright as after a season of soupy fog. For writers, these times in the fog and clouds re-introduce us to the magic in so many things, and when we return to the page it all pours out in fresh new colours.
I don’t want anyone to feel they’ve stumbled into an ambush, so here’s a heads-up that I’m going to mention my faith. It’s a more personal perspective on the core of the whole experience, but I’ll understand if you’d rather skip ahead to the next section.
Over the years, I’ve mostly understated how bad it got, especially on public platforms. The reality was pretty dark at times. There were long stretches of several months when the exhaustion, pain, and dull-mindedness were crippling. Work and socials were was impossible, books were incomprehensible, walking was agony. There was no escape, no outlet for stress. Restlessness became volcanic. It was like being a prisoner in my own body. There was only one lifeline that held, and that was my faith. I could have chosen to be angry with God for allowing something that seemed so unfair, but even though it can feel good in a self-destructive way to rage against God, I’ve seen before how quickly that road leads into a desert. So I took the decision away from my emotions, chose to trust God’s goodness, and grasped the lifeline. Instead of falling into depression, which is typical of this disease, I’ve actually gone the other way and found more peace, hope and joy than I’ve ever known before. After a while I understood why.
It’s easy to think of God more as the giver than the gift, like a kind of divine Santa in the sense that we want more from him than of him. When our arms clutch many things, even good things, we can have limited space for God. When our arms are emptied, we mostly begin by pleading for restoration, perhaps even demanding it. But if we can move past the outrage and quiet ourselves, gradually, in the absence of distraction, we find ourselves being wooed by God, and find him to be a greater treasure than any we lost.
There’s much I could say on this, but one thing that’s relevant to writing involves the pressure. I’ve mentioned before how it can slow progress because of the clangour it introduces to the quiet place where shy inspiration is coaxed from hiding. I would have expected the noise to become even louder through these years of minimal progress, particularly the last 18 months, but somehow it has been displaced more and more with this vast peace. I know the peace that comes from disciplining one’s thoughts. This is something of a different nature and on a different scale – an ocean instead of a puddle – and I can only attribute it to God. In terms of writing, I have no doubt that the resultant clarity of thought will make a considerable difference to the quality and pace of future work.
The Way Out
Perhaps the first step in recovering from sickness is knowing that you’re sick – and preferably knowing what from. Since being diagnosed, I’ve done a great deal of reading on how to manage the disease, and the changes are already showing results. Evidence of this is the fact that I was finally able to finish a blog article, though it took an unusually long time and resulted in a week-long flare-up of symptoms that interrupted the work. Since the plan is full recovery, I’ll obviously need to keep away from such activities that make high demands of mind or body.
Unfortunately, ME has no FDA-approved cure, though rintatolimod is waiting in the wings – at a price that has wings of its own. There are, however, behaviour modifications and some meds that can reduce the chance of relapses, smoothing the way to full recovery. They are gentle nudges, but in the right direction, and direction is everything when trying to escape a bewildering thicket of illness. My neurologist said that if I responded well, it might be about six months before I started to feel like a normal person again and another six until full recovery.
There’s a deep sense of relief in finding answers to something like this, in knowing that it’s an illness one can recover from. This realisation has pushed aside concerns that I burned myself out on a level so deep that a good day’s work would never again be possible. It also tells me that the intolerable slowness of progress reflects illness, not ability, and that when the illness passes, I should be able to get back to a normal pace of life and work. I expect that waking up to normal energy levels and a clear mind will feel like starting the day with about 20 espressos. Friends will probably need to stand back while I learn to manage the comparative overload. There will be a lot of life to catch up on.
Certainly, there are many reasons why I look forward to final recovery, but high on the list is the fact that I have many more books in me and every intention of getting them out to you at a respectable pace. As to how much is left to be done on the next book, it all depends on what I find when I’m able to get back into it. The sections produced during the years of illness were only ever written on clear-headed days, so I don’t foresee any wholesale replacement of big chunks, but I’ll almost certainly need to do a thorough consolidating rewrite – cleaning it up and ironing it all out.
My sincerest thanks to all of you who’ve stuck with me over the years of disappointing progress and not knowing (along with me) what was happening. I hope you’ll find the continuation of the series worth the cost of standing by a sick author. I’ll post again when I’m out of the thicket and working through the revisions. See you on the other side.
It’s settling to see here that I am not the only one who considered this book a masterpiece.. it will haunt me for a long time if an illness prevents Renshaw from becoming one of the best fantasy writers of his generation. I will await book 2 with an eagerness.
I hope your recovery happens in a magical way. That you land on your feet like Aeden did, ready to start the next adventure with a new power.
I just finished Daw of Wonder and couldn’t wait to tear into the second book. Though I am disappointed, I wish you all the best and hope you get a complete recovery.
I’m happy re listening to book 1 over and over it is epic. Keep your head up. You are loved.
It has been over 12 months since this post, therefore I assume you’ve struggled to respond well as your neurologist suggested. I’m sorry you’re going through this. There are plenty of trials in normal life and so it sucks that you get to enjoy the additional burden of this challenging debilitation.
I am 1 fan among many, but through our shared faith I count you brother. If the comments below are to believed, I am not alone in this. We wish you well. If there is anything specific we can pray for we are here.
(Though I hope it would be someone in your life who would communicate this and not you directly so that you may focus what energies you have on the way out.)
God bless.
I just came to check in on you and see that you have a pull quote from me on the front page! (I’m the Book In The Bag reviewer.)
As a person who has suffered debilitating pain and fatigue from a number of autoimmune disorders (including another “dumping ground” one) please know that I completely understand what you’re going through. I know several people with ME/CFS and I know it can be brutal. I am so so sorry this has fallen to you.
I do thank you for your book. It has kept me distracted from my own pain and fatigue many times.
I will keep you in my sincerest prayers and you have all my good wishes. —Katherine
So glad to hear you have found hope. One of the best days of my life was when I was diagnosed with Crohn’s disease and began treatment. For the 7-8 years leading up to the diagnosis I felt every bit of what you described, where my brain was foggy and just laying on the floor was exhausting. So many attempts and failures. Afterwards things got better for 15 years. Then, 7 years ago, chronic migraines, literally every day. One of the things that helped me was to befriend people with more serious illnesses who inspired me to keep going. After years of treatment and lifestyle changes I have been coming out the other side of that challenge, too, and am about to restart a career. I recently went walking in the desert and felt the very thrill and wonder you described so well. All the best, God Bless.
Heartfelt wishes for a swift and full recovery.
You should start a patreon to help with finances
I thought I would check in and see how the progress is going for Book 2. I am glad to hear you have received a diagnosis – not that ME (CFS) is what a person wants to hear. I have a few good friends who have had this diagnosis and it is rough… I am so blessed to hear of your Faith in God. We don’t know why God allows so many things but our hope is not in this life but in our future life in eternity with the Lord. I will keep you in prayer – in the mean time I always love to reread to book. God bless you Jonathan and may you receive amazing healing and peace.
Here I am reading Dawn of Wonder again.
It really is my favourite book of the last decade.
Praying for you and that joy and energy will be restored.
Thank you. I’m wishing you the best.
Thank you very much for your brave post, but very saddened to hear of your stuggles with ME. You have the most amazing gift for story telling and I wish you could just write your own of a speedy recovery and back to full fitness.
I am sending you my very best wishes, thoughts and prayers that your good days come more often than your bad and your courage carries you onwards to the other side.
Just found and finishing the first of The Wakening books.
I absolutely loved the entire thing.
I am highly anticipating the next book.
I wish you a speedy recovery/balance with your illness.
Thank you for writing and creating this world!!
Thank you for sharing your journey. You created a work of great beauty. I am eagerly awaiting the sequel. Incidentally, I read it to all of my children, who are now adults, and remember it as a great memory of our shared time together while they were growing up. You have a whole family of fans, hope you can feel our gratitude.
I can’t explain how much your first book helped me. The idea that I was more than the scars from my father was a light in the dark even at my age. At least once a month I come to this page hoping you heal and can continue brightening peoples lives with the stories you write.
We are here and we are indeed still waiting.
Wish you get well 🙂 thank you for your update:)
My husband and I loved listening to Dawn of Wonder and I checked out your website. Thank you for your courage and clear explanation for what is going on in your life. We send our warmest best wishes for you on your path to recovery and applaud your candor and honesty.
Your path is not a easy one and we hope that your talent and drive as an author will be helpful in keeping you going during the low spots.
As Winston Churchill once said “Never, never, never give up.”
We are looking forward to the next edition of the book.
My wife has suffered through six years of chronic illness. It has been very challenging as her illness has many symptoms in common with what you face. While I may not have suffered physically, I understand what it is like to have your life changed in an instant by pain that cannot be diagnosed or treated immediately. However, despite the circumstances we also have chosen to trust God and His goodness and we have been deeply blessed with a better marriage, peace, and strength. I trust God is doing the same for you. My prayers for your recovery and that God would use your suffering to bless others.
Thank you for writing Dawn of Wonder and continuing the work on future books. I’ve enjoyed your writing since I purchased DoW on audible 8 years ago. I’m also grateful for your blog updates. I look forward to whatever comes out of this season as I know it will be worth the read.
Thank you for posting. We’ve been dealing with the same illness for over a decade. I’ve been checking your blog on and off since you released the book and was surprised to see you talking about this sickness which has had such a profound impact on the life of my family.
Alright, Alright, I’ll wait then!!!
Seriously, good luck Jonathan. That 1st book was the best written book I’ve ever read. Still to this day. I’m sold on your story and think fondly of it often. Have done since my first read. 4 times now and it still draws me in.
I hope you can find the will and courage to carry on as I’m sure many of us wish. ME is an awful illness and for many it’s hard to understand. Wishes and thoughts for you and your family. When or if it gets finished won’t diminish the incredible piece you have already produced.
Josh
Filmsim events